Home
There's no intellectual property protection for food recipes. And everyone has access to the same ingredients as their local restaurants, at least for the most part. You might think that the gap between great cooking and merely competent cooking would shrink over time, as the recipes and methods of the greatest chefs leak into the mainstream.  But that doesn't seem to be happening. There is enough art in cooking that you either have that skill or you don't. At the highest level, you're part psychologist, part visual artist, part explorer, and your sense of smell is freakish. Collectively, call it an x-factor.

A few years ago I went to an oddly named restaurant called The French Laundry. It's billed as one of the greatest restaurants in the world, and you need reservations months in advance. I'm no foodie, so I didn't expect much, frankly, beyond high prices. Instead, I experienced a euphoria that transcends words. There was something about the order and proximity of tastes that lit up my brain's pleasure centers in the most unexpected way. Calling whatever happened there "eating" would truly miss the point. The place is a mood enhancer masquerading as a restaurant. It borders on pharmacology.

I was thinking about this as an analogy to where the Internet is heading. Consider a web site like www.Newser.com that summarizes content from all over the Internet. They get away with it by quoting or rewording only the most interesting points from larger bodies of work, and providing a link if you'd like to see the rest. Apparently their business model conforms to copyright laws because they are still in business. Newser has borrowed from my blog, and that's okay with me because it drives traffic this way.

Consider that Newser has access to the same raw ingredients as anyone else. Newser's website design is little more than a grid of boxes. The photos - and this fascinates me - are nothing but stock photos that have at best a casual relationship to the story they are summarizing. I mention this site because I am psychologically addicted to it. I feel a need to check it twenty times a day. WTF?

Newser's business reminds me of cooking in the sense that there is no barrier to entry. Everyone has access to the same ingredients, which in this case is content from the Internet. Anyone can summarize that content and put it in little boxes on a website. Anyone can buy stock photos. But there's something else going on.

Editors are the chefs of the Internet. Newser works, I believe, because somewhere in their back kitchen is an editor who has an uncommon feel for what stories to highlight, how to summarize them in a folksy voice, and in what order and combination they should appear. There's some genius happening there. When I read news from other places, I often come away feeling deflated. When I read Newser, I always leave in a good mood. That's why I return so often. It's a mood enhancer masquerading as some sort of news site.

And that's your future of the Internet. The cost of content, such as this blog, and my comic strip, will continue to approach zero. The art will happen with the editing. Others have made the obvious point that editing will be important for the future of the Internet. All I'm adding is the notion that most editors have skill, but few are artists. The world of print publishing is driven by editors who are exceptionally skilled. But they aren't artists. Newser is edited by an artist. He or she isn't giving me information; he's adjusting my mood. That's art. That's the future.

I know my readers, and you're going to piss all over poor Newser for being simplistic in design, having annoying ads, dumbing down the news, and stretching the limits of copyright. We can agree on all of those points. I'm just saying the editor is an artist.

 
Rank Up Rank Down Votes:  +77
  • Print
  • Share
  • Share:

Comments

Sort By:
-3 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 22, 2010
NEW YORK (Reuters) – Supporters and opponents of a proposed Muslim cultural center and mosque

near the World Trade Center site staged competing rallies in downtown Manhattan on Sunday, kept

apart by police and barricades.

The emotionally charged debate, which has gained national political significance, centers on plans to

build the center two blocks from the site of the September 11, 2001 attacks by al Qaeda, which

killed nearly 3,000 people.

Republicans against the project are using it to attack Democratic President Barack Obama ahead of

midterm elections, where his party is fighting to retain control of Congress.

Opponents of the center, which would tn requins, tnrequins.fr
include a prayer room, say its proposed location is insensitive

and fear it will harbor religious extremism. Those who back it chaussures puma, chaussures-puma.fr cite the right to religious freedom and a

need to promote tolerance and understanding.
 
 
-2 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 22, 2010
The final results of Saturday's vote may not be tn requin, www.tn-requin.org
known for a week or more but both Labor and the

Liberal Party-led opposition conceded neither would achieve the 76 seats needed to form a

government in the 150-seat lower chamber.
 
 
-1 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 22, 2010
The final results of Saturday's vote may not be tn requin, www.tn-requin.org
known for a week or more but both Labor and the

Liberal Party-led opposition conceded neither would achieve the 76 seats needed to form a

government in the 150-seat lower chamber.
 
 
Aug 22, 2010
Scott, if you like newser, may want to check out Newsy (newsy.com) video news summaries curated across sources - and The Week Magazine (theweek.com).

Will
 
 
-1 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 19, 2010
WASHINGTON (AP) -- A 22-mile-long invisible mist of oil is meandering far below the surface of the

Gulf of Mexico, where it will probably loiter for months or more, scientists reported Thursday in the

first conclusive evidence of an underwater plume from the BP spill.

The most worrisome part is the slow pace at which the oil is breaking down in the cold, 40-degree

water, making it a long-lasting but unseen threat to vulnerable marine life, experts said.

Earlier this month, top federal officials cheap air jordans, cheap-air-jordans.us declared the oil in the spill was mostly "gone," and it is gone in

the sense you can't see it. But the chemical ingredients of the oil persist more than a half-mile

beneath the surface, researchers found.
 
 
Aug 19, 2010
Whenever I have met a very capable person, regardless of the field they are working in, I have always felt like I've been watching an artist at work. The best professionals make you feel that way.
 
 
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 19, 2010
tapeworm, larryh77, tapeworm.
 
 
Aug 19, 2010
Hey, Scott,

How come when the PHB wears a turtleneck he loses his fat tummy??
 
 
Aug 19, 2010
I've been to The French Laundry dozens of times -- it's in my wife's hometown of Fenton, MI. I've never needed a reservation, but sometimes I've encountered a two hour wait (at which point I go elsewhere). The food there is fantastic.

Google tells me that there's another restaurant, of the same name, in California. I'm guessing you're referring to that one. :)
 
 
Aug 18, 2010
I know patent law fairly well, and my interpretation of it is that a recipe is patentable as a composition of matter and/or as a manufacturing process.
 
 
Aug 18, 2010
Interesting. Some rich people have personal chefs. And if the value of anything that can be converted to 0s and 1s is approaching zero, then maybe a personal editor is in my future... A mind-blowing, artificially intelligent editor that virtually reads my mind to feed me addictive stories... An editor so perfect, so addictive, that I give up on human contact, give up on real life... I even let it dream for me...

And then THEY TURN US ALL INTO BATTERIES
 
 
Aug 18, 2010
NUTS!

I KNOW NOW.

I knew then.

But now I know there is no edit button.
 
 
Aug 18, 2010
Great cooks now the chemistry of food.

Great editors now the psychology of their target audience.

 
 
Aug 18, 2010
I'm not a Newser user myself, but its creator Michael Wolff has recently written a very interesting piece for Wired about the not so bright future of the Web: http://www.wired.com/magazine/2010/08/ff_webrip/all/1
 
 
Aug 17, 2010
I see people falling head-over-tails for sites that look like this quite often. I don't really get it. I find it visually chaotic and hard to filter for interesting items.

I have similar windows preferences, too. I hate icons and tiled interfaces, while many people seem to love them. I'm constantly resetting windows to "detailed list view" so I can see file names, dates, and sizes.

I'm guessing that different people process information differently. I know lots of people who prefer lists to icons, but I've met quite a few people (my wife as an example) who love pictures and icons as metaphors.
 
 
Aug 17, 2010
I see people falling head-over-tails for sites that look like this quite often. I don't really get it. I find it visually chaotic and hard to filter for interesting items.

I have similar windows preferences, too. I hate icons and tiled interfaces, while many people seem to love them. I'm constantly resetting windows to "detailed list view" so I can see file names, dates, and sizes.

I'm guessing that different people process information differently. I know lots of people who prefer lists to icons, but I've met quite a few people (my wife as an example) who love pictures and icons as metaphors.
 
 
+4 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 17, 2010
Newser? Are you kidding me?
Its design is simplistic, it has annoying ads, it dumbs down the news, and it stretches the limit of copyright.

Sorry guys, but someone had to do it.
We wouldn't want to disappoint Scott...after all, he already has the iPhone, aka 'disappointment in your pocket', and that's enough for one person.
 
 
Aug 17, 2010
Interesting post. Who is Newer's head chef? Google thinks it's Caroline Miller according to a few old articles about the site, but I don't see her here: http://www.newser.com/behind-newser.aspx

Maybe they're getting management advice from Dogbert.
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 17, 2010
> There's no intellectual property protection for food recipes.
You really did have to direct attention to it, did you?

Copyrighted Recipes. Coming to an internet connected fridge/food processor near you.

Scared Greetings.
 
 
+10 Rank Up Rank Down
Aug 16, 2010
OK, that was quite surreal. Like a disturbance in the force or some sort of loop.
I go to Dilbert.com to read scotts adams blog which is about another website providing a news service. I go to that site and read a news article about how scott adams wrote about their news site on his blog.
So I come back to scotts blog and read other people's comments about scotts blog about the news service which refers to scotts blog referring to them................

Stop it guys, you're scaring me.
 
 
 
Get the new Dilbert app!
Old Dilbert Blog