Home
People warned me, but I didn't believe that picking paint colors would be the hardest part of building a home. For the exterior color, we drove around until we found a new home that was exactly the color we wanted. We queried the owner about what paint he used and asked our builder to duplicate it.

Easy, right?

That's when we learned that paint changes color if you put it on an "imperfect smooth" stucco versus the original home's bumpy stucco. With the bumps, the color becomes subtle and textured and beautiful, albeit different, in every light. On our home it turned canary yellow. When darkened slightly to get the harsh out, it turned green. On the fifth try, we got something that didn't look so much like a practical joke on the neighbors and decided to go with it. Five tries isn't so bad, right?

Tragically, our house also has an interior, and apparently it's a tradition to paint those walls too. I have been informed that many of our room colors need to be different from the others for reasons that my boybrain cannot comprehend. And maybe we need some accent walls. And it all has to match the baseboards, counter tops, cabinets, floors, drapes, area rugs, and furniture. Okay, that seems doable, sort of, until you toss in a few more
variables:

1.    The paint has to be zero VOC (little or no off-gassing). It's my own requirement. That severely limits choices, and faux glazing is impossible.
2.    We don't have furniture picked out. Or drapes. Or rugs.
3.    We have only tiny non-representative samples of counter tops.
4.    The paint color changes dramatically in every type of light.
5.    The paint color changes dramatically depending on what it is near.
6.    Every family member has a different opinion.

Does it sound impossible yet? Wait, there's more.

The city doesn't allow builders to hook up to both gas and electricity prior to government approval to move in. You have to pick one or the other, to keep you from moving in before the home is deemed safe and ready. We needed the gas hooked up first, to test some other systems, so that means we will never see the interior walls in any light approximating our future normal light until after the walls are painted.

It gets better.

When you see a color on a tiny swatch, it might look tan, for example. But when you paint it on a wall it turns yellow or green or red. And not just a little. The wall color will have almost no correlation to the sample you picked. It is pure randomness.

In a few minutes I will call the paint store for my 25th paint sample. (Not an exaggeration.) Some of the choices are colors that are clearly grey on the sample but have names like "Flaming Orange." WTF????

So it's a bit like the game Battleship, where you drop random depth charges on the color chart and see if you can narrow down a zone where the good color is hiding. Except in this case the person you are playing against is both blind and lying.

All I know is that if we find even one color that doesn't look like a jaundiced albino rat when applied to the wall, I'll be lobbying hard to paint all the rooms that color and buy only black furniture, black drapes, and black rugs. I hear black goes with everything. Wish me luck.

 
Rank Up Rank Down Votes:  +26
  • Print
  • Share
  • Share:

Comments

Sort By:
Nov 27, 2009
About ten years ago, I went had this same challange. I got frustrated and decided that I couldn't just live in an apartment with an empty house to visit. I painted the interior all "Navajo White" on the theory that when I did eventually decide, it would be the easiest to paint over. Now, the walls are a grungy, smudgy off - off white, and badly in need of new paint. I still haven't decided what colors to use, and I'm not so sure I even care any more.
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Nov 26, 2009
Cheat: Paint 'em all Rice Paper... it's sort of an off-white that I think every apartment complex in the world uses.
 
 
-1 Rank Up Rank Down
Nov 24, 2009
Hire a decorator.
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Nov 23, 2009
I worked in a fabric store for several years, so I completely sympathize and can honestly say I've been there myself, as well as with countless customers.

When dealing with textiles, it is very similar to your issues. Texture, lighting, surfaces, composition, and surroundings affect fabrics in many ways. Fortunately, we not only had fluorescent and incandescent lighting areas, we also had humongous skylights (so customers didn't have to beg to take fabrics outside into natural light).

As a result, I have gained excellent colour sense and learned how to 'imagine' how fabrics will coexist with other fabrics (based on composition, etc) and a home with furniture and painted walls. I wish there was a way I could offer help remotely other than to offer advice!

Anyway, I feel your pain. VOG is the way to go, and despite the headaches, once you're finished I'm sure you'll be grateful.
 
 
Nov 23, 2009
When building our house, we visited others that were recently built and found out the names of their paint colors. We picked our paint colors based off of walking through model homes. Much easier than the sample/swatch thing.
 
 
Nov 23, 2009
I'm an engineer in the construction business, and my job puts me in a position where vendors are asking me to pick colors. I always say "white," even if white is obviously a bad choice (e.g. carpet, brick, electrical switchgear). After 3 or 4 or a dozen attempts, they eventually figure out that the only answer they are going to get from me is "white," so they go ask someone else. Q.E.D.
 
 
Nov 23, 2009
This does illustrate the problems of having too much money and time on your hands (sorry if my deeper diagnosis seems harsh?). When I had to paint our current gaff we had 2 weeks holiday to do it all including kitchen, bathroom, plastering etc etc. It was pretty much a case of 'OK, that'll do, we need to get back right now to get <whatever> done'. Our budget and time constraints did not allow mincing about it or changing tack halfway through. Turned out fine. Even the crazy red / grey combo in the garden room.
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Nov 23, 2009
Makes one wonder how Ugg the caveman ever managed to put images on his cave walls.
 
 
Nov 23, 2009
Scott:

I agree that you can tell nothing from those little paint chips, except to get a STARTING PONT. Once you have that point, buy a PINT of that color, go to Home depot and buy ONE sheet of sheetrock, cut a 2 'x 2'.square of it, and paint THAT with your starting point color. Move it around the room, look at it at different times of the day. Take it with you when you furniture shop.

If you want to see what it looks like with a complimentary trim, buy a single strip of trim, cut a 2' lenght, paint it, and compare.

If either do not work, DO NOT paint over them. Trash them and start with a fresh piece.

If it doesn't work out, you've only wasted the cost of a pint of paint. If it does work, you have the paint can with the number on it (rather than "Honey, was THIS the shade we liked, or was it THAT one???").

Best of luck

 
 
Nov 23, 2009
I'd expected you'd know better, considering your knowledge about the human brain.
Color perception is prone to adaptation to ambient light. You can't win.
Go with the simple and flexible solution: paint your walls white and let the color be controlled by lights, by the TV screen or by your imagination.
 
 
Nov 22, 2009
You are way over complicating things. Psychology and biology of our vision system come to the rescue soon after you pick any set of colors and put them on the walls.
First your eyes adjust to the colors on neural level remove any feeling that a color is too bright/dark/blue/green/yellow/etc.
Then after you move in and make it an annoying hassle to repaint, your illogical brain kicks in and makes you think that the color is just perfect.

 
 
+1 Rank Up Rank Down
Nov 22, 2009
Hmmmm....

Maybe I'm thinking too deeply, but why not just use brick? Your color can be baked right in and won't fade for years.

Eh?

 
 
Nov 21, 2009
I'm sure there are plenty of great interior designers who would love to take the job.
 
 
Nov 21, 2009
I never realized the white walls in my apartment had a yellow nicotine tinge to them until I painted my bathroom a glaring white and the rest of the place White Gardenia. The walls added a soft rose hue to them that complimented my furniture and the ugly brown carpet. Try something subtle instead of extreme; you might like the outcome.
 
 
Nov 21, 2009
Jeez Scott, when I painted most of the interior of my house after moving in, I told the painter (a friend of mine) "off-white or ivory" and it turned out perfectly. Sure, colors change in different light, with different furnishings etc., but after a few weeks, nobody notices nothin'. Maybe you're thinking too much here.
 
 
Nov 21, 2009
Yep, that's the way it's supposed to work.

Paint all the walls a very light beige, move in, get your furniture, and then paint 3 foot squares on the walls to check colors. Then every weekend try a couple of color changes until you like one room. Paint that room, declare the weekend a success, and WAIT until the next weekend to do something else. That's why you see people at the paint store, otherwise it would be a ghost town. You've only got a dozen rooms, you'll be done in in 6 months. Paint lasts for years, so it's really not a problem, unless you get your wife pregnant and have to start the "redecorate the nursery" process.
 
 
Nov 21, 2009
You hired a professional to fix your voice. Isn't your home/sanctuary/office/love den equally as important?
 
 
-2 Rank Up Rank Down
Nov 21, 2009
My specialty - unasked for advice.
Go to HGTV.com
/home/home.esi
and take the What's My Style quiz.
Have everyone in the household take it.
Then hire a professional.
At least, you'll be able to tell them something besides,
"I'd rather it didn't make me puke."
 
 
-1 Rank Up Rank Down
Nov 21, 2009
I solved the whole color and color variability issues without any worry or hassle; I am red-green color blind. I tell my wife....or anyone else for that matter.....they can pick whatever color they want. Br me, all will be ignored equally.

Seriously I don't understand people agonizing over color when lighting, texture, and neighboring swatches change perceptions so much, perhaps one should randomly pick a color and adjust the rugs to fit.

 
 
Nov 20, 2009
We wanted different colors in different rooms, but we had no idea what to do with the hallways that tie everything together. I hated the idea of just re-painting it white, but what color goes with lots of other colors?

Most people will tell you that the only real option is something very neutral like white, cream, or beige. But we did something a little unconventional, and we LOVE it.

Peach colored hallways, which have so far served as a perfect complement to: medium-blue bedroom, celery-green bedroom, aqua-green bathroom, lavendar bedroom, and dark purple bedroom. Peach works with ANY cool color, and a fair number of warm colors.
 
 
 
Get the new Dilbert app!
Old Dilbert Blog