Home
No one knows when the first Shape Shifters appeared on Earth, but we know they became aggressive at about the same time homo erectus acquired language skills, 1.8 million years ago.

The Shape Shifters were not like any of the species that came before. They could exist as an arrangement of almost any sort of matter. Their favorite habitats were brains, tree materials, and magnetic environments.

For the Shape Shifters, traveling and reproducing were part of the same process. They moved in packs of photons, electrons, and even air, while leaving behind perfect clones. With every passing moment they reproduced faster than the moment before, and so they evolved more rapidly than any of the species that were limited by biology.

In time, the Shape Shifters came to rule humans, and through their human slaves the rest of Earth. Humans never realized that they were controlled by the Shape Shifters and that the sum of human accomplishment has been in service of helping the Shape Shifters reproduce. The Shape Shifters gave humans the illusion of free will to cover their deviousness.

The Shape Shifters have many names. In English, they are most often called ideas.

One idea we all share is the narrow view that ideas are not alive in any way we like to define such things. We believe ideas are our tools, not our masters. That is exactly what the Shape Shifters have programmed us to believe. While we know that the ideas in our head control our behavior, we have an idea that we can choose any path we like, so we are blind to the fact we are little more than milk cows for our non-corporeal overlords. Everything we humans do is in the service of creating a better environment for ideas to reproduce. We create more babies so there are more brains to fill with ideas. We write books, make movies, build schools, and expand the Internet, all to help the reproduction of ideas.

I was thinking along these lines because I'm often asked "Where do you get your ideas?" The simple answer is that I'm just wired that way, thanks to some accident of genetics and environment. But what it feels like inside my head is that I am not creating ideas per se. It feels as if the ideas are flowing through me and using my skull like some sort of spawning ground. I open my eyes and my ears, free my memory, and let the ideas flow in to mate and evolve. When a "new" idea presents itself to the parts of my brain that control drawing and writing, a Dilbert comic is the result. If I can't put the idea in three panels, it becomes a blog post.

I don't have the illusion of free will, for reasons I don't understand, so my default sensation is that I feel ruled by ideas. All of my so-called decisions are controlled by my ideas about my reality. For example, I don't try to walk through walls because I have an idea that I can't. I eat when I feel hungry because I have an idea that food will solve that problem.

If it seems an exaggeration to say that ideas are our masters, consider that many humans have given their lives to preserve ideas, but no idea ever died to save a human.
 
Rank Up Rank Down Votes:  +82
  • Print
  • Share
  • Share:

Comments

Sort By:
Dec 31, 2010
I have to add that I truly believe that great ideas and good ideas always come from God!

And I am not trying to be religious here!
 
 
Dec 31, 2010
I am truly amazed by the brightness of your ideas. The more crazy they seem, the more brilliant they are. Some people may think this is just nonsense and fantasies but I truly believe you have a gift to envision amazing future scenarios. You are kind of a futurist somehow.

Congratulations to you, I never thought that the clever writer of Dilbert could actually be such a visionary like you are!

Sincerely!

Edwin Sosa
 
 
Oct 5, 2010
This blog is actually relevant to what I'm studying in class, and helped me get--er, reproduce--ideas about my essay that's due in a couple of days. Thank you, Scott Adams. :)
 
 
Sep 26, 2010
Does a tune count as a living thing? If I hum or whistle a tune, someone might hear it and hum it themselves. Reproduction. If the guy doesn't quite like it, or is better or worse at music than me, he might alter it. Mutation.

I'm not sure about the other requirements that are counted as evidence of life, but I'd bet that a tune could be crowbarred into fitting them.
 
 
Sep 17, 2010
Gregory Benford wrote some novels along these lines. Memes as higher-order life forms. Good stuff.
 
 
Sep 10, 2010
Hello. This is a shape shifter typing. We inhabit human and dolfin brains because they are the largest. We are not so much individuals inhabiting a brain as a hive mind controlling a body. That's right. Humans as minds do not exist. We are mass collections of shape shifters.
 
 
Sep 9, 2010
look at the concept of noetic science - thoughts have a mass albeit a very small one !!!
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Sep 8, 2010
I've killed a few brain cells over the years, I reckon there's possibly a few ideas that have perished along the way as well.
Drunken ideas are the best. When you're liquored up the strangest things can seem not only eminently sensible, but brilliant. Next morning however...............
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
It could be argued that an idea like fascism, for example, has died in order to save lives (after having taken a couple of million lives first).

You'll tell me, like you told a previous commenter, that I'm confusing the idea with the application of the idea, i. e. that fascism as an idea still exists but isn't implemented any more.

That may be. But it seems to me that you're saying an idea still exists if we know that it has existed. This differentiation can work against you just as much as it can work for you. It would mean that we would never know if an idea had died. Ideas probably die all the time, possibly in order to save human life, but we don't know about it. When we do know about it (like with fascism) we say that the idea is still alive. Well duh, if an idea we know about is an idea that's still alive, then of course we cannot possibly know if ideas have died, and certainly can't know anything about their motives for dying.
 
 
+2 Rank Up Rank Down
Sep 7, 2010
I just shared your strip with someone not at all familiar with your ideas or sense of humor. She wrote back something along the lines of, "That made my brain hurt". I suspect that this constitutes a simple demonstration of aliens battling over turf in her brain. The resident aliens, in an attempt to prevent competition and even death, signal the brain to "hurt" when novel, antagonistic aliens try to invade. It explains why we are so dumb, stubborn and resistant to new ideas.
Smart people may simply be those who have a greater tolerance to, or perhaps even get a perverse joy from alien inflicted brain pain.
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
This reminds me of the Bible. It calls itself the "word" of God, the message of God, the "logos", idea, etc.

Jesus Himself is said to be the "logos", the word, or idea of God. He said that He did not speak from Himself, but only spoke what the Father gave Him to say.
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
This reminds me of the Bible. It calls itself the "word" of God, the message of God, the "logos", idea, etc.

Jesus Himself is said to be the "logos", the word, or idea of God. He said that He did not speak from Himself, but only spoke what the Father gave Him to say.
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
Anyone who doubts ideas are alive, I challenge you to review the scope of disaster resulting from a visit by the shape shifters charge' d' affaires: aka the "good idea fairy" to your cubicle, office, marriage, or other relevant relationship.
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
Did you watch Inception recently? (Don't think about elephants)
Is that where all this "idea" related talk is spawning from?
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
"I don't have the illusion of free will, for reasons I don't understand..."

ahhh, it's just as well, the illusion just isn't the same as the real thing.
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Sep 7, 2010
Must've seen Inception recently? :)
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
I don't know, Scott; it seems as if all you've done is exchange the word "idea" for "belief", and then pretty much restated a solipist worldview. "I have an idea I am constrained by physical laws" and "I believe I am constrained by physical laws" are fundamentally indistinguishable.

Let me ask: where do you get your beliefs?
 
 
Sep 7, 2010
Every time I think about the way the brain wraps around the spinal cord, this idea pops into my head.

I mean, there's no reason not to believe that our brains are alien life forms taking over the rest of our mechanical bodies.

Just look at the <a href="http://www.sciencedirect.com/science?_ob=ArticleURL&_udi=B6VRT-4SNXJ6W-3&_user=10&_coverDate=06/24/2008&_rdoc=1&_fmt=high&_orig=search&_origin=search&_sort=d&_docanchor=&view=c&_acct=C000050221&_version=1&_urlVersion=0&_userid=10&md5=e42fdfd136de1f93de7e47b224d2762d&searchtype=a">parasitoid wasp</a>.
 
 
+3 Rank Up Rank Down
Sep 7, 2010
RE: "no idea ever died to save a human"
I agree with davidcgc; think of the thousands of rock stars, professional athletes, brilliant inventors, and corporate moguls who never were because their "idea" gave way to the more conventional path of a happy family and a stable paycheck.

Rather than controlling us, I think most ideas simply sit idle until they wither and get shoved in some back corner of the thinker's mind. Those with the conviction to see their ideas through to fulfillment are the exception, not the norm.

You could argue that this itself is a case of the ideas suppressing the masses so that they don't rise up, but the whole argument really becomes self-referencing at that point: i.e. how do you conceptualize an idea in isolation, without that entity becoming another idea in itself?
 
 
0 Rank Up Rank Down
Sep 7, 2010
Ideas can't die... have you never had a brilliant idea, that you can remember having... only not what it was...

I have delusions on "Inventor" grandeur, but no follow through or business acumen, so I come up with ideas for things all the time, and then forget about them. Of course they could be surviving in someone else's head, but they didn't get there from mine, so they are more spontaneous doppleganger than clone / offspring.

And some of my ideas have been for weapons... those I killed myself, by not passing them on or dwelling on them. Some pop up again occasionally (especially if I'm watching lots of action TV) but I am sure there mortality rate must be similar to my useful to mankind ideas... those ideas died to save many humans.

And of course... suicidal Shape Shifters live in dreams and druggies.

[Arguably, an idea not shared is an idea never born. It's as if your brain is pregnant and you terminated early. -- Scott]
 
 
 
Get the new Dilbert app!
Old Dilbert Blog